For former Auburn Tigers football star Robert Civer and former cheerleader wife Lindsey, it seemed like the perfect life. They have his three beautiful sons, his $2.5 million home in Georgia, and a vacation home in the Bahamas to boot. That’s where dreams come from.
But that doesn’t seem to be the case, as Lindsay, her 28-year-old foreign lover, and a hit man were all arrested on suspicion of plotting the murder. Former college football star.
Police arrested Lindsey, 36, her girlfriend Terrence Bethel, 28, and hitman Fallon Newbold, 29, in Abaco. suspected intrusion at Glover’s Bar and Grill on Great Guana Cay, according to bahamas court news. Authorities searched the WhatsApp app on one of the suspects’ mobile phones and identified a message plotting to kill Robert.
Georgia woman arrested in Bahamas on suspicion of plotting to murder husband of former Auburn football player
Lindsay Shiver, 36, was arrested after Bahamas police stumbled upon an alleged plot to kill Robert Shiver, 38, while investigating another case. pic.twitter.com/jvANrD1VZa
— Daily Loud (@DailyLoud) July 30, 2023
According to a police report via Bahamas Court News, “On July 16, 2023, in Abaco, while together, they agreed to commit a crime, namely the murder of Richard Civer, for a common purpose.”
Lindsay, Bethel and Newbold were all flown to Nassau, Bahamas. So they appeared before a judge, but were not required to file a petition. WTVYMore. (Related: Kansas offensive lineman Joe Krause arrested in bomb threat, police say)
They are scheduled to appear in court again on October 5.
