Let’s be clear: if Elon Musk decides to launch a third party in 2025, it could be one of the most misguided moves in political history, much like how Bill Clinton found his way to the White House in the ’90s. This idea isn’t bold or visionary; it could actually be detrimental to Americans who want to see our country course-correct.
I mean, I actually like Elon. I’ve appreciated his defense of free speech and admired his ability to stand up to the so-called awakened mob. I think, often, his instincts are right on the money. But the moment he ventures into starting a so-called “centrist” third-party initiative, he could unintentionally pave the way for Gavin Newsom, Pete Buttigieg, Josh Shapiro, or JB Pritzker to have four years to carry on their agenda, which many believe is harming the nation.
This really isn’t complicated. History shows that third parties don’t win; they tend to spoil elections. And that’s not just an opinion—it’s a well-documented fact. In 1992, Ross Perot disrupted the conservative vote and handed victory to Clinton. Ralph Nader played a role in Al Gore’s loss in 2000. Fast forward to 2016, and Jill Stein and Gary Johnson siphoned votes from both major parties. Even Kanye West in 2020 didn’t make much of a difference but demonstrated how vanity projects can disrupt the political process.
The only ones who benefit when a third party gains any traction are… well, they think they do, but it usually isn’t how it plays out. And Elon is aware of this reality.
Right now, it seems like the political landscape has just two paths: one aims to save America, while the other veers dangerously close to socialism. If Musk’s new party manages to pull 3-5% of voters away from conservative candidates or the Republican Party, the consequences could be dire.
It genuinely doesn’t take much. Just a couple of crucial points in states like Georgia, Arizona, Wisconsin, or Pennsylvania, and we could find ourselves facing open borders and soaring gas prices again.
I get it. Musk is frustrated. Trust me, I am too. The GOP isn’t perfect by any means. But burning down the whole establishment because of a few leaks isn’t the solution. We need to fix the issues, not tear everything apart.
Donald Trump didn’t just hijack the Republican Party; he revived it. Under his leadership, we’ve gained a real opportunity to restore some sense of rationality in our politics.
Elon’s potential third party feels more like a whimsical idea from Silicon Valley, dressed up in libertarian rhetoric. A party that insists on simply “trusting the data” and claims “they’re all bad” isn’t going to win against the Democratic machine. This isn’t some TED Talk; it’s a gritty fight for the essence of our nation.
This whole notion is particularly disappointing for young conservatives like me. We’ve organized, mobilized, and voted to shift the direction of this country. Gen Z seems to be stepping up, yet here we are voting for fewer taxes, no taxes on overtime, a grassroots return to energy independence, all while Musk seems poised to throw a spanner in the works.
This isn’t bravery; it feels like a betrayal.
If Elon wants to contribute, that’s great—he can use his platform to fund conservative candidates and keep challenging the left’s excessive narratives. But he shouldn’t jeopardize a realistic path to victory.
There seems to be too much focus on personal ego and experimentation. We’re at a crossroads—either we choose freedom or we slide into tyranny. If Elon goes through with this, history might remember him not as a revolutionary but as a person who inadvertently aided Joe Biden in dismantling the very fabric of America.
Elon, you’ve done some amazing things. But this? This isn’t one of them. Please be wise. Stay engaged in the fight, but don’t disrupt it.
