Pima County Attorney Laura Conover, who had planned to acquit Louis Taylor of the arson and murder convictions in the 1970 Pioneer Hotel fire in Tucson, said she had received “a letter from a Phoenix attorney.” After “threats,” it decided not to, new court documents claim.
Pima County Attorney Laura Conover
Rebecca Sasnett, Arizona Daily Star
Last month, Taylor’s attorneys filed a motion to remove Conover, the county’s top prosecutor., and Jack Ching, a former county attorney general on the release of public records.
The motion included an affidavit from Nina Trasoff, a former TV news anchor and former member of the Tucson City Council. Trasov said in her affidavit that she was good friends with Conover and volunteered to edit news releases for her office.
Shortly after taking office as president in 2021, Conover told Trasoff that he planned to look into Taylor’s case and prove his innocence. He helped compile a news release about the acquittal that was to be issued, court records say.
People are also reading…
“Early last week, after 17 months of intensive research, our team came to a perhaps predictable conclusion. And I will never act based on political or media pressure. “Last week, the Pima County Attorney’s Office concluded that it could no longer uphold the conviction of Lewis Taylor in the 1970 Pioneer Hotel fire… the wounds of injustice continue to bleed to this day, and we are guilty We are filing a motion to reverse the judgment.”
Court records show Trasoff said Conover was thrilled by the fact that the review showed that the fire was not arson and that Taylor was wrongfully convicted.
However, that news release was never released to the public.
Instead, months later, the county attorney’s office issued a news release stating that Conover had decided not to drop the criminal charges against Taylor. He said.
As they discussed the new decision, Trasoff said Conover told her he had decided not to go on board with the original news release.
Neither the name of the attorney nor the motive for the threats against Conover in the Pioneer Fire case were included in the court documents.
When asked about the allegations in court records on Wednesday, Conover released the following statement: In the performance of my duties as a prosecutor, I have demonstrated my willingness and ability to listen to a variety of feedback. But I also proved that I make decisions based on facts and the law. I carefully consider the views of my senior leadership team and interested community members, but the final decision is my own. ”

Louis Taylor greets former attorney Howard Kashman (back to camera) as he is surrounded by judicial project attorneys in Pima County Superior Court in 2013, shortly before his release from prison. .
Benji Sanders, Arizona Daily Star
Taylor was convicted of causing a fire in downtown Tucson that killed 29 people and served 42 years in prison. In 2013, Taylor signed a deal with the office of former Pima County Attorney Barbara Lawall to have his conviction reversed., and released him from prison.
Taylor has pleaded not guilty. In 2015, The Star reported that Taylor sued Pima County and the city for violating due process and the right to a fair trial. However, Taylor was barred from seeking damages for his time in prison as part of a no-challenge petition he made.
Had Taylor been acquitted, he could have sought compensation for his wrongful conviction.
The controversy surrounding Conover in the Pioneer Fires is nothing new. Critics say her involvement in Taylor’s case poses a conflict of interest.
Before she resigned, Lawor’s office hired an outside attorney to represent the county in Taylor’s civil case. Conover said this was because he did research for Taylor’s parole hearing while in law school. The office also said that during campaigning for the 2020 county attorney’s election, Conover discussed her dismay about how the case was handled, Starr reported.
Conover has dismissed these claims.
Conover said the conclusion LaWall’s team had reached was wrong, saying, “Twenty years ago or later, Taylor’s representation, whether he was in law school or not, was also part of his representation. No,” he said.
Photo of the Pioneer Hotel fire in downtown Tucson in 1970

The Pioneer Hotel never recovered from the 1970 fire, said Bettina Lyons, niece of the couple who owned the hotel. “They put money into it and put a sprinkler system in, but people didn’t stay.”
Jack Schaefer / Arizona Daily Star

Victims are removed from the main entrance of the Pioneer Hotel in December 1970.
Jack Schaefer / Arizona Daily Star

Injured firefighters are carried into an ambulance during the Pioneer Hotel fire on December 20, 1970.
Arizona Daily Star File

Ultimately, the Pioneer Hotel fire killed 29 people, some of whom jumped out of windows to escape the blaze. Louis Taylor was convicted of arson. The first article appeared in The Star on December 20, 1970.
1961 Pioneer Hotel.
Arizona Daily Star File

Firefighters in an old Tucson fire engine help a woman descend from a high-rise during the Pioneer Hotel fire on December 20, 1970.
Arizona Daily Star File

Firefighters spray the upper floor windows of the Pioneer Hotel fire on December 20, 1970.
Arizona Daily Star File

A man stands by one window on the upper floors of the Pioneer Hotel fire on December 20, 1970.
Arizona Daily Star File

Firefighters rescue an unidentified man after extracting him from a room near the top floor of the Pioneer International Hotel, which caught fire in early December 1970.
Manuel Miera/Tucson Citizen

Tucson firefighters apply a constant stream of water during the Pioneer Hotel fire in December 1970. Tucson’s firefighting equipment was deemed inadequate after this fire as it was unable to help many trapped on higher floors.
Tucson citizen

During the fire at the Pioneer Hotel in December 1970, flames and smoke erupted from the windows on the upper floors.
Tucson citizen

During the Pioneer Hotel fire in December 1970, flames and smoke rose from the upper windows as firefighters extended ladders to save people on the floors below.
Tucson citizen

Victims are removed from the main entrance of the Pioneer Hotel in December 1970.
Manuel Miera / Tucson Citizen

The victim was removed from the main entrance of the Pioneer Hotel in December 1970.
Tucson citizen


Smoke rises from the upper floors of the Pioneer International Hotel. A firefighter at the bottom helps an elderly pioneer tenant down a ladder.
Jack Schaefer / Arizona Daily Star

Firefighters help the injured in the Pioneer Hotel fire, December 1970.
Jack Schaefer / Arizona Daily Star

During the Pioneer Hotel fire in December 1970, hotel patrons helped to safely descend the ladder.
Tucson citizen

Pioneer Hotel Fire
Arizona Daily Star

Tucson firefighters climb a ladder during the 1970 Pioneer Hotel fire.By: Tucson Fire Department
Tucson Fire Department

Tucson firefighters help an elderly patron descend a ladder during the Tucson Pioneer Hotel fire on December 20, 1970.
Arizona Daily Star

Catering manager GL Scoggins speaks with Tucson firefighters exhausted after the December 20, 1970 Pioneer Hotel fire in Tucson.
Arizona Daily Star

Tucson firefighters exhausted after the Pioneer Hotel fire in Tucson, December 20, 1970.
Arizona Daily Star

People wrapped in blankets outside the Pioneer Hotel in Tucson after a deadly fire on December 20, 1970.
Arizona Daily Star

People in downtown Tucson look up at the Pioneer Hotel the morning after the great fire of December 1970.
Dan Tortrell / Tucson Citizen

People in downtown Tucson look up at the Pioneer Hotel the morning after the great fire of December 1970.
Dan Tortrell / Tucson Citizen

Aftermath of the Pioneer Hotel fire in December 1970.
Tucson citizen

Aftermath of the Pioneer Hotel fire in December 1970.
Tucson citizen

A suite at the Pioneer Hotel owned by the Steinfeld family, owners of the Steinfeld department store. The couple died in a massive hotel fire on December 20, 1970.
Arizona Daily Star

The aftermath of the Pioneer Hotel in December 1970.
Tucson citizen

Funeral for victims of the Pioneer Hotel fire in December 1970.
Tucson citizen

1970, Lewis Taylor. He was tried and convicted of 28 counts of felony murder in connection with the fire at the Pioneer Hotel in Tucson.
Harry Lewis / Arizona Daily Star

Arizona prison inmate Louis C. Taylor, serving a life sentence after being convicted of the 1970 Pioneer Hotel fire that killed 28 people. 29 people subsequently died from burns.
Arizona Department of Corrections

After a hearing in Pima County Superior Court in Tucson, Arizona, on Tuesday, April 2, 2013, Louis Taylor returned the hands of his first attorney from 1972, Howard Cushman, back to the camera to reveal the current state of Phoenix. lawyers surround him. Taylor, who was initially convicted of his 28 felony murders related to the fire, was released from prison after 42 years.
Benji Sanders/Arizona Daily Star
Get your morning recap of today’s local news and read the full story here: tucne.ws/morning
Jamie Donnelly covers breaking news for the Arizona Daily Star. Please contact her on her email. jdonnelly@tucson.com
be the first to know
Get local news delivered to your inbox.