According to the Free Press, a current college student said he was reportedly denied the title in a debate competition after his opponent resurfaced a tweet he wrote.

Matthew Adelstein said how his hopes of winning the National Speech and Debate Association (NSDA) were dashed Monday. Article free press. Adelstein alleges that during a debate at the Tournament of Champions in April 2022, he attacked his character by revealing a reply the opposing team tweeted earlier in the month. (Related: Court rule allowing high schools to expel students for racist social media posts about classmates)

Psychology professor Jeffrey Miller tweeted:[n]It’s one of those things that you personally find morally disgusting, but think rationally should be legal and socially acceptable. “

According to the newspaper, Adelstein wrote in response that she was “calling people racist and homophobic slurs.”

Here is my tweet and his reply.
He agreed that he considered racial or homophobic slurs morally offensive. But wouldn’t his failure to advocate those legal censorships disqualify him from winning a high school debate competition??🤔🤔 pic.twitter.com/vpuBVLWVmW

— Jeffrey Miller (@primalpoly) June 26, 2023

The federal government’s influence on water resources, a subject of debate, is said to have been ignored. Instead, Adelstein’s opponents allegedly ranted over 25 pages on issues unrelated to the topic of their assigned debate. according to Document obtained by Free Press.

The debate judge awarded the victory to Adelstein’s opponent, stating:[a] A discussion space where racist and violent people are not allowed is preferable to a place with racist and violent people,” the media noted. “Ballot papers have the transformative power to challenge white debate norms that allow racism and violence to go unchecked,” he argued.

Some coaches have punished students for being “anti-black” or “transphobic,” the newspaper reported.previous work Suspect NSDA judges have publicly threatened to punish students for arguments in favor of Israel and capitalism, he said.

According to footage obtained by the media, Quest Sandel, who served as MP at the 2019 NSDA Nationals, instructed students not to use gendered language.

“I don’t want to hear the word Mr or Miss from anyone. We try to respect the differences of each person here, so that’s very much appreciated,” he told the Free Press. reported.

15-year-old debater Briana Whatley told the media outlet that the contest did not reflect what debate should be.

“In NSDA tournaments, winning is not guaranteed based on my reasoning, facts, or statements, but rather whether I strengthened the ideology of the judges through debate,” Whatley said. “It’s the antithesis of a true public debate.”