Breaking News Stories

SELLERS: Misinterpreting the Path to Independence

The Olive Branch Petition: A Precursor to Independence

Before the Declaration of Independence, there was the Olive Branch Petition.

Written 250 years ago on July 5, this document marked Thomas Jefferson’s first attempt to address King George III, explaining the American colonies’ rebellion while seeking reconciliation.

At that time, Jefferson had been dismissed nearly three months prior for a separate issue. The recent Battle of Bunker Hill had just concluded, and it was evident to the Second Continental Congress that tensions were escalating beyond control. In a last-ditch effort to halt the rebellion and advocate for peace, John Hancock permitted the drafting of documents that articulated the colonial stance, expressed loyalty to the king, and proposed a solution to the ongoing conflict.

For the colonists, the king’s representatives governed most political matters, and the authority of the royal governor was generally accepted, as if the king himself were present. However, what the settlers failed to grasp was the gradual undermining of the king’s power as the British Constitutional government strengthened Parliament. A crucial aspect of this power struggle revolved around financial control. The king and Parliament engaged in ongoing discussions about taxation and spending.

During this period, while the roles of the king and Parliament were being defined, the colonies worked on establishing their own political frameworks. Initially, they developed with minimal input from the crown. The British subjects’ practices were subtly shifted as colonies adopted local forms of autonomy that, at times, were nearly invisible. Legislative structures were largely accepted due to their familiarity, but, most importantly, they proved effective.

The colonies, in need of new revenue to meet the demands of both the crown and Parliament, became an untapped financial resource. The Continental Congress justified taxing the colonies by arguing that the costs of protecting them from foreign threats should fall on the direct beneficiaries. Starting in 1764, Parliament aimed to impose various taxes on the colonies. While the king did benefit from these taxes—some of which supported his royal courts—the taxes were framed as parliamentary initiatives rather than direct royal decrees.

Consequently, each tax added to the settlers’ frustrations, prompting many to find ways to evade the new levies. They resorted to actions like smuggling and boycotting. Some took more direct measures such as damaging property in protest. Throughout these acts against Parliament’s decisions, settlers believed that if King George grasped their grievances alongside Parliament’s role, he might mend relations. They did not realize the king’s complicity in the imposed taxes.

As tensions intensified and Redcoats were ordered to disarm colonial militias, mere rhetoric escalated into genuine conflict, resulting in loss of life and property destruction. Events in Lexington, Concord, and Bunker Hill were not simply law enforcement actions; they represented a significant military conflict with serious consequences. As the situation deteriorated, the Continental Congress made a final appeal to the king through the Olive Branch Petition. The initial draft of this petition, crafted by Jefferson, was deemed overly aggressive, leading fellow founder John Dickinson to moderate its tone before it was approved and sent to the king.

Unfortunately, King George never took the time to read the petition. Instead, he opted to suppress the rebellion, issuing his own declaration of rebellion that allowed the execution of leaders. The Olive Branch Petition aimed to prevent violence and re-establish amicable relations between the crown and the colonies; however, by dismissing it, he ultimately pushed loyalists into rebellion.

Within a year, Jefferson’s Declaration of Independence would chart an unavoidable trajectory, culminating in Washington’s victory at Yorktown and effectively resolving the conflict.

Share this post: