Protests Erupt Over Teacher Reassignment in Sacramento

On Wednesday, students from a sixth-grade elementary school in Sacramento, California, stepped outside their classes to join their parents in a protest against the reassignment of a beloved teacher.

Students at Phoebe Hearst Elementary School demonstrated in support of Janine Rupert, who, while still employed by the Sacramento City Unified School District (SCUSD), was removed from her teaching position. Reports indicate that her reassignment stemmed from an incident at the end of the previous school year when Rupert and her students took out an old carpet from her classroom due to what they believed was a flea infestation. Parents claimed the district hadn’t acted despite her repeated requests.

The district expressed concerns that removing the carpet could have disrupted asbestos tiles beneath it, which might pose health risks, according to various reports.

However, a statement from SCUSD on September 4 clarified that no damage had occurred. They stated, “The investigation into the issue concluded earlier this week, confirming that the asbestos tiles were not damaged while students were present.” They further assured families that they would initiate outreach to confirm students’ safety and provide necessary support.

Nearly 100 parents and students voiced their dissatisfaction with Rupert’s reassignment during a school board meeting. Many parents, who remained anonymous, praised Rupert’s dedication to her students, mentioning her supportive role both inside and outside the classroom.

One parent, James Frasie, argued that his daughter was treated unfairly, lacking due process in the decision. Rupert’s father, Tim O’Brien, expressed his concern, explaining how hard the situation has been for her. “She had been trying to replace that carpet for five years and felt she had no choice but to do it herself. She’s devastated; she brought life to Phoebe Hearst,” he said.

Some students voiced that had they been helping with the carpet removal, their parents wouldn’t have panicked. “I wouldn’t have worried if it was my child lifting that carpet,” remarked Lindy Burge, a parent at the school, pointing out that the tiles had remained intact.

Parents also raised concerns about the consistency of their children’s education, stating they want Rupert back. “Ultimately, Rupert wants to return. The kids need stability,” Burge added, emphasizing the impact of the uncertainty on their education.

Rupert has been at Phoebe Hearst Elementary since 2000.